Marketing Explained

The Big Secret Behind Email Marketing: A/B Testing

There’s no magic emoji. How to A/B test subject lines, sender names and send times, and structure tests you can actually trust.

Key takeaways

  • A/B testing beats guessing; expect steady 2–20% lifts, not 500% overnight wins.
  • Test subject lines, sender names and send times, changing only one variable at a time.
  • Use a big enough sample, run both versions at the same time, and revisit results every 3–4 months.

Transcript

What is A/B testing? A/B testing, also called split testing, is a simple yet powerful technique. You take two versions of an email, change one or more elements, and send each one to segments of your audience. The version with better performance typically becomes your winning email. Ascertaining the elements that did better can be tricky, which is why we recommend doing multiple A/B tests with small changes to make it easier to tell what worked and what didn’t.

When we look at A/B testing, one of the main things to think about is there are no magic bullets. And I know that sounds strange, because there are a lot of YouTube Shorts and people on TikTok saying, “Hey, just add this one emoji and it’s going to radically increase your open rates by 500%.” There are some things that can help. When we’re doing this type of A/B testing, we’re usually looking for an increase between 2 and 20%, 50% on the high end. And we do recommend doing this testing with a list as small as 100, because we are doing percentage-based increases. So a 2% increase on a list of 100, or on a list of 10,000 or 50,000, is a radical increase.

Now, why even bother with it? Is it just a waste of time? We get these questions a lot as an agency. The truth is, guessing doesn’t work. It’s a shot in the dark and often leads to wasted resources and missed opportunities. A/B testing, on the other hand, is a proven method for uncovering what truly resonates with an audience.

So what elements should you actually test? First, test your subject lines. They’re the first thing the audience sees and can make or break whether your email gets opened or not. One way to test is questions versus statements, such as “Need a gift? Here’s the perfect idea” or “The gift everyone will love.” Questions can spark curiosity, while statements might appeal to those seeking a straightforward solution. Another angle to explore is personalization versus generic lines. A personalized subject line like “Hey [name], we’ve got something special for you” can feel more tailored and engaging.

Second, experiment with including or excluding sender names. Sometimes a personalized sender name like “John from your company” can build trust and increase open rates, while other times a straightforward company name works best.

Timing can also have a significant impact on your email open rates, and it’s one of the most overlooked factors in email marketing. To maximize engagement, it’s crucial to test different send times and days of the week to pinpoint your audience. Are they early risers who check their emails first thing in the morning, or are they night owls who scroll through their inboxes late at night? For example, if your audience is younger, chances are they’re more active in the evening or even late at night. However, it’s important to note that these patterns can shift dramatically over time.

Now, structuring your A/B test effectively is absolutely crucial to ensure you get reliable and actionable insights. Start by creating two distinct versions of your email, but with one important rule: change only one variable at a time. This could be the subject line, the call to action, the imagery, or even the tone of the copy. By isolating a single variable, you eliminate the guesswork and can confidently pinpoint what’s driving the difference in performance. For example, if you’re testing subject lines, keep everything else in the email identical. This way you know any variation in open rates is solely due to the subject line being tested.

Equally important is using a significant sample size to ensure your results are statistically accurate. A good rule of thumb is to aim for at least a thousand recipients per variant. You can do it with 100, but having a thousand really helps. For larger lists, you might even consider testing with 2,000 to 5,000 recipients per variant. Finally, run your tests simultaneously to account for external variables like day of the week or seasonal influences. By following these steps, changing one variable, using a large enough sample size and ensuring a fair split, you’ll set yourself up for a successful A/B test that delivers clear, actionable insights to optimize your campaigns.

That’s why it’s essential to revisit your email analytics every 3 to 4 months to stay updated with your audience’s behavior. What worked 6 months ago might not work today, and staying ahead of these trends can give you a competitive edge. During this testing process, remember that small changes can lead to big results. It may seem menial or unnecessary at first, but there’s a reason any good marketing platform has A/B testing built in, like ActiveCampaign. As an agency, we’ve sent thousands of emails, and we know that just a single emoji doesn’t always work.

Want help putting this into practice? See Email marketing for financial advisors.

More episodes

Can AI-Generated Content Get Your Website Penalized by Google?

Marketing Explained

Google isn’t banning AI content, but it is targeting how it’s used. What the scaled-content policy means for your website, and three steps to stay safe.
Demand Generation Is a Lie: Capture the Demand That Exists

Marketing Explained

You can’t create demand from nothing. Smart firms find the people who already have the problem, show up in front of them, and make the decision easy.

Marketing Explained

Creating and cultivating a brand image is essential for any business, but what exactly is a brand? It’s more than a logo, a product, or a promise- in this episode, we’ll reveal the secret of how to leverage your brand for success! In this series all about marketing, learn about what branding is, and how to create an authentic brand for your business.

Want your own content studio?

We set up the camera, lights and audio in your office and train you to record. One session becomes 8 to 10 pieces of content.